- Public transit adds up: Ditching the car in favor of public transportation can save up to $10,000 per year in San Francisco.
- Driving isn’t a major time win to begin with: Commuting by car instead of public transit saves nearly 25 minutes per day, which is less than in other car-dependent cities.
A recent Point2Homes study looked at the 30 largest U.S. cities to determine how much money commuters (particularly renters) can save by switching from driving to using public transportation. San Francisco stood out in terms of potential savings, with the analysis adding another reason to leave the car at home: the time saved by driving instead of taking the bus isn’t significant enough to outweigh the financial benefits.
While most commuters nationwide rely on cars to get to work, things look a bit different in San Francisco. Less than 48% of commuters drive to work, fewer than in other major cities like Seattle, WA (62%), Chicago, IL (65%), or car-dependent California hubs like Los Angeles and San Diego.
In San Francisco, the cost of commuting is more than just a matter of time — it’s a matter of thousands of dollars each year. And, as one of the most expensive cities in the U.S., its public transportation system can be a financial lifeline, especially for renters.
Ditching the Car Can Save San Francisco Renters $10,000 a Year
Once you factor in fuel, insurance, maintenance, and parking, the average cost of commuting by car in San Francisco exceeds $11,100 annually. Public transit, on the other hand, costs under $1,000 annually, leaving nearly $10,000 in potential savings for those who make the switch.
For those renting in San Francisco, giving up the car goes beyond reducing emissions — it’s about regaining control over their budget. The average renter household here earns about $9,600 per month and could save the equivalent of more than one month’s income each year by opting for public transit.
In other words, commuting by car eats up nearly 9% of a renter’s salary. By comparison, owner households have a median monthly income of around $15,200, making the cost of a car commute equivalent to about 5.6% of their annual earnings.
In a city already grappling with affordability issues, cutting that much from monthly expenses could make it easier for renters to keep up or even build some financial cushion.
Does Driving Also Save Time in San Francisco? Yes, But Not Enough to Warrant the Cost
San Francisco is one of the few big cities where driving a car can really increase commute costs without providing a huge time advantage in return.
While commuting by car is usually faster, car ownership can come at a sky-high premium here. Yet, despite the financial incentive of public transit, many still choose to drive because of time.
San Francisco drivers do enjoy shorter commute times than those who rely on public transit, with under 25 minutes per day saved. Over a year, that adds up to roughly 108 hours, or just over 4 days. While not insignificant, the minutes saved are modest compared to the national average of over half an hour. It’s also less than the time saved in car-centric cities like Las Vegas or San Jose, where commuters can save over 50 minutes a day by driving instead of taking public transport.
For renters facing tight budgets, saving thousands of dollars a year on commuting could mean the difference between scraping by and gaining some financial breathing room to put toward rent, loans, or more savings.
Methodology
Point2Homes.com is a real estate listing portal for rental homes across the United States. Part of Yardi Systems, Point2Homes covers housing trends and news through comprehensive studies that draw from internal data, public records, governmental sources, and online research.
- For this study, we considered the 30 most populous U.S. cities, per the U.S. Census American Community Survey (ACS 2023), with a focus on San Francisco.
- Data about means of transportation to get to work, tenure by vehicles and commute time for the 30 largest U.S. cities were also sourced from the U.S. Census American Community Survey (ACS 2023).
- Data on fuel and maintenance costs was sourced from AAA, car insurance costs from Bankrate, and parking rates from Spothero.
- Data on the financial cost of public transit commuting in each city was sourced from APTA and local transit authority websites.
- The median income for the renter and owner households at the national level and also for the 30 cities used in the analysis were sourced from the U.S. Census American Community Survey (ACS 2023).
Image: seand67/Shutterstock.com
Fair use and redistribution
We encourage and freely grant permission to reuse, host or repost this article. When doing so, we only ask that you kindly attribute the authors by linking to Point2Homes.com or this page, so that your readers can learn more about this project, the research behind it and its methodology.
