Bay Shore, NY houses for rent
No luck – your dream rental is playing hard to get
If your perfect match isn’t here, it might be time to compromise… just a little!
Get to know Bay Shore, NY
Know your way around
Car-dependent
Walk Score®
No data
Transit Score®
Somewhat bikeable
Bike Score®
Bay Shore is mostly car dependent. Limited services and amenities are within walking distance, so a car is needed for most errands. Bay Shore is a somewhat bikeable area with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use.
Walkability data provided by Walk Score®
See what’s nearby
Paul J Bellew Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 456 students
Idle Hour Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 190 students
Bretton Woods Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 512 students
Edward J Bosti Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 283 students
Tooker Avenue School
Public • PK, K-5 • 291 students
Pines Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 457 students
Anthony Alfano Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 586 students
John F Kennedy School
Public • PK, K-5 • 335 students
Santapogue School
Public • PK, K-5 • 348 students
Gardiner Manor School
Public • 3-5 • 702 students
Southwest Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 980 students
South Country School
Public • 3-5 • 469 students
Hemlock Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 617 students
Oak Park Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 711 students
Bay Shore Middle School
Public • 6-8 • 1298 students
West Middle School
Public • 6-8 • 848 students
Bay Shore Senior High School
Public • 9-12 • 1910 students
North Clinton Avenue & Union Boulevard
Bus
Union Boulevard & 3rd Avenue
Bus
Suffolk County Bus
Bus
Mechanicville Road & Park Avenue
Bus
Union Boulevard & 4th Avenue
Bus
Platform A
Train
Bay Shore
Train
Bay Shore
Train
Platform B
Train
North Clinton Avenue & Union Boulevard
Bus
Union Boulevard & 3rd Avenue
Bus
Suffolk County Bus
Bus
Mechanicville Road & Park Avenue
Bus
Union Boulevard & 4th Avenue
Bus
Platform A
Train
Bay Shore
Train
Bay Shore
Train
Platform B
Train
Platform B Overpass
Train
Platform A
Train
Taco Bell
Food
Quiznos
Food
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Food
Unfriendlys
Food
The Pizza Shack
Food
KFC
Food
Subway
Food
McDonald's
Food
McDonald's
Food
Southside Hotel
Drinks
Kitty Mulligan's
Drinks
The Penny Pub
Drinks
Destination Unknown Beer Company
Drinks
Schooner Inn
Drinks
Taco Bell
Food
Quiznos
Food
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Food
Unfriendlys
Food
The Pizza Shack
Food
KFC
Food
Subway
Food
McDonald's
Food
McDonald's
Food
Chowdar Bar
Restaurant
Flynn's Fire Island
Restaurant
Mustang's Restaurant and Fried Chicken
Restaurant
The Lakehouse
Restaurant
J&R's Islip Steak House
Restaurant
Blaze Pizza
Restaurant
Gino's Pizza
Restaurant
Jon Thomas Inne
Restaurant
Big Daddy’s East
Restaurant
JCPenney
Shopping
Macy's
Shopping
Westfield South Shore
Shopping
Garage Sale Store
Shopping
Target
Shopping
HomeGoods
Shopping
Staples
Shopping
Best Buy
Shopping
Long Island Comics (Historic)
Shopping
7-Eleven
Grocery store
King Kullen
Grocery store
ShopRite
Grocery store
ALDI
Grocery store
Saltaire Market
Grocery store
Brook Avenue Deli
Grocery store
Stop & Shop
Grocery store
Joe's Kwik Marts
Grocery store
7-Eleven
Grocery store
JCPenney
Shopping
Macy's
Shopping
Westfield South Shore
Shopping
Garage Sale Store
Shopping
Target
Shopping
HomeGoods
Shopping
Staples
Shopping
Best Buy
Shopping
Long Island Comics (Historic)
Shopping
Field 4
Automotive
Private Parking
Automotive
M B Automotive
Automotive
Conoco
Automotive
Unpaved Parking Lot
Automotive
Field 5
Automotive
BP
Automotive
Shell
Automotive
Cart Parking
Automotive
Field 4
Automotive
Private Parking
Automotive
M B Automotive
Automotive
Conoco
Automotive
Unpaved Parking Lot
Automotive
Field 5
Automotive
BP
Automotive
Shell
Automotive
Cart Parking
Automotive
Southside Hospital
Healthcare
CVS Pharmacy
Healthcare
Northwell GoHealth Urgent Care
Healthcare
Margarita Villas
Hotel
Bay Shore Inn
Hotel
Travelodge
Hotel
Tonis barbershop
Personal care
Salons By JC
Personal care
Maily S Magic Nail
Personal care
Calvary Baptist Church
Place of worship
Temple Sinai of the South Shore
Place of worship
First Congregational Church
Place of worship
St. Peter's by-the-Sea Episcopal Church
Place of worship
Love & Mercy Fellowship
Place of worship
Gospel Lighthouse Pentecostal Church
Place of worship
Unity Greater Highway Church
Place of worship
Kingdom Hall of Jehovah’s Witnesses
Place of worship
Saint Lukes Lutheran Church
Place of worship
Bay Shore Post Office
Public service
Saltaire Village Office
Public service
Bay Shore Post Office
Public service
Village of Saltaire
Public service
Teachers Federal Credit Union - Lester J Gosier
Public service
Bay Shore Fire Department Headquarters
Public service
UPS
Public service
Brightwaters Village Hall
Public service
3rd Precinct - Suffolk County Police Department
Public service
Fresnel Lens Building
Entertainment
Bay Shore - Brightwaters Public Library
Entertainment
Bay Shore Historical Society
Entertainment
Loews Bay Shore Twin (Historic)
Entertainment
YMCA Boulton Center For The Performing Arts
Entertainment
Sundance (Historic)
Entertainment
Sagtikos Manor
Entertainment
Bay Shore Marauders
Sports
Casamento Park Pool
Sports
Fresnel Lens Building
Entertainment
Bay Shore - Brightwaters Public Library
Entertainment
Bay Shore Historical Society
Entertainment
Loews Bay Shore Twin (Historic)
Entertainment
YMCA Boulton Center For The Performing Arts
Entertainment
Sundance (Historic)
Entertainment
Sagtikos Manor
Entertainment
Bay Shore Marauders
Sports
Casamento Park Pool
Sports
24 fitness
Sports
Planet Fitness
Sports
Retro Fitness
Sports
Average rent in Bay Shore
In Bay Shore, the average rent is $2,460 per month, with the average rental size around 771 square feet. Most renters here pay between $2,000 - $2,500, making it the most common rent bracket in the area.
Average rent
$2,460/month
Average rental size
771 sqft
Rent ranges
- Under $1,000
- 0%
- $1,001 - $1,500
- 0%
- $1,501 - $2,000
- 15.5%
- $2,001 - $2,500
- 41%
- $2,501 - $3,000
- 31.6%
- Over $3,000
- 11.9%
Rent data provided by Yardi® Matrix.
Average utility cost in New York
In New York, renters typically spend around $470 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for internet to $148 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.
Electricity
$148
$148
Gas
$144
$144
Water
$34
$34
Sewer
$55
$55
Cable
$59
$59
Internet
$30
$30
Find houses for rent near you – Start your search on Point2Homes
Looking for a house to rent nearby? Point2Homes makes it easy to explore updated listings for single-family homes and detached rentals near your current location. Whether you're searching for a cozy house, a spacious family home, or a pet-friendly property with a backyard, we’ve got you covered.
Browse houses for rent by price, number of bedrooms, amenities, and neighborhood, right from your phone or desktop. You can compare square footage, locations, and resident insights to make the best decision. Expand your search to nearby suburbs, cities, or even across the U.S. if you're ready for a bigger move.
Wherever you're headed, the right rental home is waiting. Let Point2Homes help you find it quickly and easily.