Central Islip, NY houses for rent
No luck – your dream rental is playing hard to get
If your perfect match isn’t here, it might be time to compromise… just a little!
Get to know Central Islip, NY
Know your way around
Car-dependent
Walk Score®
No data
Transit Score®
Somewhat bikeable
Bike Score®
Central Islip is mostly car dependent. Limited services and amenities are within walking distance, so a car is needed for most errands. Central Islip is a somewhat bikeable area with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use.
Walkability data provided by Walk Score®
See what’s nearby
Parkview Elementary School
Public • PK, K-3 • 405 students
Paul J Bellew Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 456 students
Bretton Woods Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 512 students
Idle Hour Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 190 students
Edward J Bosti Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 283 students
Lincoln Avenue Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 453 students
Edith L Slocum Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 272 students
Pines Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 457 students
Anthony Alfano Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 586 students
Francis J O Neill School
Public • K-6 • 614 students
Marguerite L Mulvey School
Public • K-6 • 526 students
Anthony Alfano Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 586 students
Cordello Avenue Elementary School
Public • K-6 • 507 students
Charles A Mulligan School
Public • K-6 • 981 students
Ralph Reed School
Public • 7-8 • 1149 students
Central Islip Senior High School
Public • 9-12 • 2576 students
Touro Law School
College
Carlton Avenue & 1st Avenue
Bus
Calton Avenue & 3rd Avenue
Bus
East Suffolk Avenue & Central Islip LIRR
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Providence Drive
Bus
Islip Avenue & Sage Street
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Seley Cross Street
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Manhattan Boulevard
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Edgewood Street
Bus
Carlton Avenue & Smith Street
Bus
Carlton Avenue & 1st Avenue
Bus
Calton Avenue & 3rd Avenue
Bus
East Suffolk Avenue & Central Islip LIRR
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Providence Drive
Bus
Islip Avenue & Sage Street
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Seley Cross Street
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Manhattan Boulevard
Bus
Connetquot Avenue & Edgewood Street
Bus
Carlton Avenue & Smith Street
Bus
Central Islip
Train
LIRR Station Parking
Train
Central lslip Station Entrance
Train
Suffolk Avenue
Train
LIRR Station Parking
Train
Suffolk / Lowell
Train
Central Islip
Train
McDonald's
Food
Out Of The Park Burgers
Food
Checkers
Food
Subway
Food
Central Pizza
Food
Nutriliving
Food
Taco Bell
Food
Subway
Food
Pollo Campero
Food
McDonald's
Food
Out Of The Park Burgers
Food
Checkers
Food
Subway
Food
Central Pizza
Food
Nutriliving
Food
Taco Bell
Food
Subway
Food
Pollo Campero
Food
Viva Mexico
Restaurant
El Nuevo Encanto
Restaurant
Delicious Chinese Reataurant
Restaurant
Miguelito
Restaurant
Cafe Latino
Restaurant
Cosmos
Restaurant
Lucky Kitchen
Restaurant
Bagels & Brunch Deli
Restaurant
Carrabba's Italian Grill
Restaurant
Target
Shopping
Bougatfa IV Halal Food
Shopping
iFixScreens Central Islip
Shopping
Metro by T-Mobile
Shopping
CVS Pharmacy
Shopping
Wine Cellar
Shopping
Family Dollar
Shopping
Rainbow
Shopping
Lempa Deli
Shopping
7-Eleven
Grocery store
C‑Town Supermarkets
Grocery store
7_Eleven
Grocery store
El Fogon Grocery
Grocery store
Cherry Valley
Grocery store
Familia Bakery
Grocery store
7-Eleven
Grocery store
BP Shop
Grocery store
Bravo
Grocery store
Target
Shopping
Bougatfa IV Halal Food
Shopping
iFixScreens Central Islip
Shopping
Metro by T-Mobile
Shopping
CVS Pharmacy
Shopping
Wine Cellar
Shopping
Family Dollar
Shopping
Rainbow
Shopping
Lempa Deli
Shopping
Hercules Auto Repair
Automotive
BP
Automotive
The Real Muffler Stop
Automotive
Gulf
Automotive
Victor’s Auto Service Center
Automotive
Shell
Automotive
BP
Automotive
B&C Auto Tech
Automotive
Speedway
Automotive
Hercules Auto Repair
Automotive
BP
Automotive
The Real Muffler Stop
Automotive
Gulf
Automotive
Victor’s Auto Service Center
Automotive
Shell
Automotive
BP
Automotive
B&C Auto Tech
Automotive
Speedway
Automotive
CVS Pharmacy
Healthcare
Oasis Dental
Healthcare
Courtyard
Hotel
2
Hotel
Residence Inn
Hotel
1129
Hotel
State Farm
Other
H&R Block
Other
Color Nails & Spa
Personal care
Erika Nails
Personal care
Green Aroma Spa
Personal care
Pet Supplies Plus
Pet care
Kingdom Hall of Jehovah’s Witnesses
Place of worship
Episcopal Church of the Messiah
Place of worship
Saint John of God Roman Catholic Church
Place of worship
Kingdom Hall of Jehovah’s Witnesses
Place of worship
Christ Pentecostal Church
Place of worship
Berkery Chapel
Place of worship
Iglesia Centro De Vida
Place of worship
Hope Missionary Baptist Church
Place of worship
Central Islip Seventh Day Adventist
Place of worship
Suffolk County Water Authority
Public service
Bethpage FCU
Public service
Citibank
Public service
MTA Police Department District 1 Central Islip
Public service
Bank of America
Public service
Suffolk County District Court
Public service
Central Islip Post Office
Public service
Central Islip Fire Department
Public service
Legal Row
Public service
Central Islip Public Library
Entertainment
Culinary Arts Center
Entertainment
Islip Town Firefighters Museum
Entertainment
Long Island Ducks
Sports
Results Gym
Sports
Central Islip Public Library
Entertainment
Culinary Arts Center
Entertainment
Islip Town Firefighters Museum
Entertainment
Long Island Ducks
Sports
Results Gym
Sports
Average rent in Central Islip
In Central Islip, the average rent is $2,849 per month, with the average rental size around 927 square feet. Most renters here pay over $3,000, making it the most common rent bracket in the area.
Average rent
$2,849/month
Average rental size
927 sqft
Rent ranges
- Under $1,000
- 0%
- $1,001 - $1,500
- 0%
- $1,501 - $2,000
- 6.8%
- $2,001 - $2,500
- 14.4%
- $2,501 - $3,000
- 39.3%
- Over $3,000
- 39.4%
Rent data provided by Yardi® Matrix.
Average utility cost in New York
In New York, renters typically spend around $470 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for internet to $148 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.
Electricity
$148
$148
Gas
$144
$144
Water
$34
$34
Sewer
$55
$55
Cable
$59
$59
Internet
$30
$30
Find houses for rent near you – Start your search on Point2Homes
Looking for a house to rent nearby? Point2Homes makes it easy to explore updated listings for single-family homes and detached rentals near your current location. Whether you're searching for a cozy house, a spacious family home, or a pet-friendly property with a backyard, we’ve got you covered.
Browse houses for rent by price, number of bedrooms, amenities, and neighborhood, right from your phone or desktop. You can compare square footage, locations, and resident insights to make the best decision. Expand your search to nearby suburbs, cities, or even across the U.S. if you're ready for a bigger move.
Wherever you're headed, the right rental home is waiting. Let Point2Homes help you find it quickly and easily.