Skip to main content
Location
Price
$
-
$
Beds & baths
Filters
Availability & specials
Lease options
Property type
Pet policy
Home size
-
Lot size
-
Year built
-
Amenities
Property rating

Tolleston, Gary, IN houses for rent

4 houses for rent in Tolleston, Gary, IN.

20
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with a black fridge, wooden cabinets, and a black stove top oven.
From $1,545 /mo

2003 Wright St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46404

4 beds 1.5 baths 1,406 sqft
View details
14
Gary house for rent - A black couch with a striped pillow sits in a living room with a glass coffee table.
Ask for pricing

4138 W. 20th Ave. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46404

3 beds 1 bath 1,081 sqft
View details
2
Gary house for rent - a small brick house with a lawn in front of it
From $1,800 /mo

1051 Lane Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46404

4 beds 1.5 baths 2,036 sqft
View details
1
Gary house for rent - A small house with a black iron gate in front.
From $1,600 /mo

4225 w 20th Place | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46404

3 beds 2 baths 1,221 sqft
View details

Look beyond, explore listings nearby!

Homes within a 10-mile radius from your location

12
Available now
Gary house for rent - 6204 W. 29th Ave.
From $1,425 /mo

6204 W. 29th Ave. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 1 bath 818 sqft
View details
18
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with a black stove top oven and white cabinets.
From $1,500 /mo

427 Rutledge Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46404

3 beds 1.5 baths 1,116 sqft
View details
17
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with wooden cabinets and a black fridge.
Ask for pricing

4377 Kentucky St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46409

3 beds 1 bath 1,207 sqft
View details
23
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with brown cabinets and a white fridge.
From $1,600 /mo

4562 Johnson Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46408

3 beds 2 baths 1,236 sqft
View details
11
Gary house for rent - A living room with a green chair and a white couch.
Ask for pricing

3940 Pierce St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46408

3 beds 1 bath 1,496 sqft
View details
26
Gary house for rent - a living room and hallway with wood floors and a painting on the wall
From $1,500 /mo

2128 Tennessee Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46407

3 beds 2 baths 2,186 sqft
View details
24
Gary house for rent - a kitchen with white cabinets and a sink and a refrigerator
From $1,595 /mo

419-23 Hobart Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 2 baths 1,050 sqft
View details
46
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with a refrigerator, microwave, and oven is visible through a glass door.
From $1,650 /mo

5060 Virginia St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46409

3 beds 1 bath 1,099 sqft
View details
12
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with white cabinets and a grey floor.
From $1,400 /mo

1013 Durbin St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

2 beds 1 bath 980 sqft
View details
6
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with white cabinets and a wooden floor.
From $1,400 /mo

1127 Burr St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

2 beds 1 bath 1,012 sqft
View details
15
Gary house for rent - A modern kitchen with a stainless steel refrigerator and a ceiling fan.
From $1,600 /mo

5207 West 4th Place | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 1 bath 1,000 sqft
View details
13
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with a stove top oven and a refrigerator.
From $1,650 /mo

769 Hamlin Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 1 bath 1,073 sqft
View details
9
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with brown cabinets and a white dishwasher.
From $1,295 /mo

3464 Pennsylvania Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46409

3 beds 1.5 baths 1,002 sqft
View details
19
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with a white refrigerator, white stove, and wooden cabinets.
From $1,400 /mo

612 Hamlin Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 1 bath 900 sqft
View details
9
Gary house for rent - a small kitchen with wooden cabinets and a window
Ask for pricing

4381 Johnson Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46408

3 beds 1 bath 925 sqft
View details
14
Gary house for rent - a kitchen with a sink and white cabinets
From $1,375 /mo

1622 Ohio Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46407

3 beds 1 bath 936 sqft
View details
7
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with a refrigerator, oven, and sink.
From $1,495 /mo

730 Clinton St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 1 bath 1,108 sqft
View details
10
Merrillville house for rent - a kitchen with a stove and cabinets and a water heater
From $1,600 /mo

945 West 54th Place | House for rent

Merrillville, IN, 46410

3 beds 1 bath 1,320 sqft
View details
19
Gary house for rent - A kitchen with wooden cabinets and a ceiling fan.
Ask for pricing

1543 Tennessee St | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46407

4 beds 1 bath 1,240 sqft
View details
1
Gary house for rent - a small yellow house with a sidewalk in front of it
From $1,600 /mo

828 Dallas Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

3 beds 1 bath 1,512 sqft
View details
1
Gary house for rent - A two-story house with a white siding and a grey roof.
From $1,195 /mo

1533 Tennessee St | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46407

3 beds 1 bath 1,800 sqft
View details
0
Images pending
From $1,400 /mo

928 Hobart St. | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46406

4 beds 2 baths 1,139 sqft
View details
2
Gary house for rent - a red brick house with a lawn and a sidewalk
From $1,700 /mo

4345 Adams Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46408

3 beds 1 bath 1,670 sqft
View details
0
Available now
Images pending
Ask for pricing

4381 Johnson Street | House for rent

Gary, IN, 46408

Studio
View details
11
Available now
Hammond house for rent - A kitchen with a sink and a window.
From $1,695 /mo

913 169th Pl. | House for rent

Hammond, IN, 46324

2 beds 1 bath 1,216 sqft
View details
16
Hammond house for rent - a white kitchen with a sink and a refrigerator
From $1,850 /mo

1008 Drackert Street | House for rent

Hammond, IN, 46320

2 beds 1.75 baths 962 sqft
View details

Get to know Tolleston, Gary, IN

Know your way around

29
Car-dependent
Walk Score®
N/A
No data
Transit Score®
35
Somewhat bikeable
Bike Score®
Tolleston is mostly car dependent. Limited services and amenities are within walking distance, so a car is needed for most errands. Tolleston is a somewhat bikeable area with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use.
Walkability data provided by Walk Score®

See what’s nearby

Frank High Hammond Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 685 students
8/10
Homan Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 475 students
8/10
Judith Morton Johnston Elementary
Public • PK, K-5 • 364 students
6/10
Beiriger Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 443 students
6/10
Peifer Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 471 students
6/10
Warren G Harding Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 684 students
5/10
Edgar L Miller Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 351 students
5/10
Lew Wallace Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 465 students
5/10
Jonas E Salk Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 587 students
5/10
Beveridge Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 310 students
3/10
11th Avenue & Roosevelt
Bus
County Market Plaza
Bus
11th Avenue & Grant
Bus
11th Avenue & Chase
Bus
11th Avenue & Roosevelt
Bus
County Market Plaza
Bus
11th Avenue & Grant
Bus
11th Avenue & Chase
Bus
Little Caesars
Food
Sharks Fish & Chicken
Food
Harold's Chicken Shack
Food
Westside Foods
Restaurant
TNT Brickhouse Soul Food
Restaurant
Little Caesars
Food
Sharks Fish & Chicken
Food
Harold's Chicken Shack
Food
Westside Foods
Restaurant
TNT Brickhouse Soul Food
Restaurant
Walgreens
Shopping
Dollar Tree
Shopping
Family Dollar
Shopping
Economy Discount Liquors #6
Shopping
Gary Printing
Shopping
Dollar General
Shopping
Boost Mobile
Shopping
Shell
Grocery store
Fresh County Market
Grocery store
Shell
Grocery store
Fresh County Market
Grocery store
Grocery Outlet
Grocery store
K & M Food Mart
Grocery store
Walgreens
Shopping
Dollar Tree
Shopping
Family Dollar
Shopping
Economy Discount Liquors #6
Shopping
Gary Printing
Shopping
Dollar General
Shopping
Boost Mobile
Shopping
Citgo
Automotive
Grant Gas & Mini Food Mart
Automotive
Shell
Automotive
Tolleston Station Gary Post Office
Public service
Robert L. Lewis & Assoc.
Public service
People's Bank
Public service
Gary Fire Department Station #3
Public service
Walgreens
Healthcare
Methodist Midlake Campus
Healthcare
Citgo
Automotive
Grant Gas & Mini Food Mart
Automotive
Shell
Automotive
Walgreens
Healthcare
Methodist Midlake Campus
Healthcare
Martha's Clip and Curl Salon
Personal care
No Limit Cutts & Creations
Personal care
Charmgurl Beauty Bar
Personal care
PHD Professional Hair Designers
Personal care
Wildwood Church of Christ
Place of worship
Olive Grove Missionary Baptist Church
Place of worship
New Bethel Missionary Baptist Church
Place of worship
Saint Paul Baptist Church
Place of worship
Bible Way Apostolic Church
Place of worship
Pilgrim Rest Baptist Church
Place of worship
Village First Baptist Church
Place of worship
New Friendship Missionary Baptist Church
Place of worship
Liberty Baptist Church
Place of worship
Tolleston Station Gary Post Office
Public service
Robert L. Lewis & Assoc.
Public service
People's Bank
Public service
Gary Fire Department Station #3
Public service

Average utility cost in Indiana

In Indiana, renters typically spend around $413 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for internet to $129 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.

Electricity grafic icon
Electricity
$129
Gas grafic icon
Gas
$89
Water grafic icon
Water
$37
Sewer grafic icon
Sewer
$69
Cable grafic icon
Cable
$59
Internet grafic icon
Internet
$30
Find houses for rent near you – Start your search on Point2Homes

Looking for a house to rent nearby? Point2Homes makes it easy to explore updated listings for single-family homes and detached rentals near your current location. Whether you're searching for a cozy house, a spacious family home, or a pet-friendly property with a backyard, we’ve got you covered.

Browse houses for rent by price, number of bedrooms, amenities, and neighborhood, right from your phone or desktop. You can compare square footage, locations, and resident insights to make the best decision. Expand your search to nearby suburbs, cities, or even across the U.S. if you're ready for a bigger move.

Wherever you're headed, the right rental home is waiting. Let Point2Homes help you find it quickly and easily.

4-26-nhood