Skip to main content

$2,112-$2,371/mo

(2)

Paragon Place at Bishops Bay

5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597

1-2 beds 1-2 baths 775-1,386 sqft

All about this rental

Quick overview

Type:
Apartment
Floors:
3
Neighborhood:
North Lake
ZIP code:
53597
Built:
2017
Status:
Active
Apartments in the community:
105
Buildings in the community:
3
Last checked:
1 hour ago

Find your perfect layout

Perks of living here

Convenience

Daily life is easier with On-Site Maintenance, On-Site Management, Private Washer & Dryer, Rentable Storage Lockers, and Recycling services.

Temperature

Stay comfortable with Central Air Conditioning, Electronic Thermostat, and Ceiling Fans.

Security

Feel secure with Controlled Access Lobby and Heated Underground Parking for added protection.

Lifestyle

Relax and socialize at the Clubhouse with Billiards, Darts, Bar & Lounge, Outdoor Patio with Firepit and Grilling Station, and the 24-hour Internet Café & Coffee Bar with Free Wi-Fi.

Fitness

Stay active with the 24-hour Fitness Center, Free Weights, and nearby Bike Trails.

Outdoors

Enjoy the Pool with Firepit and Lounge Area, Exclusive Golf Course & Park Views, and proximity to Harvey John & Lucille Taylor Park, offering pickleball courts, basketball court, football field, picnic shelter, and playground.

Design

Stylish interiors feature Open Concept Kitchens with Granite or Quartz Countertops, Stainless Steel Appliances, Kohler Gooseneck Faucets, Cathedral and Tray Ceilings, Plank Floors, and Oversized & Walk-In Closets.

Standout

Unique amenities include Bike Racks, Elevator, and an Outdoor Patio with Food Preparation Area for gatherings.

Shared spaces & benefits

  • Club Room with Billiards, Darts, Bar & Lounge
  • 24-Hour Internet Cafe & Coffee Bar with Free Wi-Fi
  • Pool with Fire Pit and Lounge Area
  • Outdoor Patio with Fire Pit, Grilling Station, and Food Preparation Area
  • 24-Hour Fitness Center
  • Free Weights
  • On-Site Management
  • On-Site Maintenance
  • Elevator
  • Recycling
  • Bike Racks
  • Controlled-Access Lobby
  • Rentable Storage Lockers
  • Close to Restaurants and Shopping
  • Bike Trails
  • Heated Underground Parking
  • Smoke-Free Community
  • Adjacent to Harvey John & Lucille Taylor Park Offering Pickleball Courts, Full Basketball Court, Football Field, Picnic Shelter, and Playground

In-house comforts

  • Open-concept kitchens with stainless steel appliances, Kohler gooseneck faucets, and countertops featuring either granite or quartz
  • Private washer & dryer
  • Expansive private patio or balcony
  • Solid-core bedroom and bathroom doors
  • Cable ready
  • Electronic thermostat
  • Central air conditioning
  • Window coverings
  • Oversized & walk-in closets
  • Disposal
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Carpeting
  • Plank floors
  • Ceiling fan
  • Exclusive golf course and park views
  • Fireplace in select apartments
  • Cathedral and tray ceilings in select apartments
  • Kohler gooseneck faucets
  • Stainless steel appliances

See what makes this place special

Ready to see it in person?

Fees & policies

General fees

Security deposit:
$750
Application fees:
$17
There may be additional unit-specific fees.

Pet policy - Cats allowed

Security pet deposit:
$500
Monthly pet rent:
$50
Pet limit 2 allowed. $50 for first pet per month. $40 for 2nd pet per month. The 1st and 2nd floors are pet-friendly. The 3rd floor is pet-free.

Pet policy - Dogs allowed

One-time pet fees:
$62
Security pet deposit:
$500
Monthly pet rent:
$50
Pet limit 2 allowed. $50 for first pet per month. $40 for 2nd pet per month. The 1st and 2nd floors are pet-friendly. The 3rd floor is pet-free.

Pet policy

Pets allowed. Maximum 2 pets per apartment. The 1st and 2nd floors are pet-friendly. The 3rd floor is pet-free. Some breed restrictions apply for dogs. No weight limit for dogs. Exotic pets are not permitted. For more information about the Paragon Place Pet-Friendly Policy and requirements, please inquire within.
The fees are estimates and actual amounts may vary. Pricing and availability are subject to change. For details, .

Contact info
Arden Property Group Inc.
Website
Property listed in the Yardi Rental ILS Network (RentCafe.com & Point2Homes.com).

Get to know the area

Know your way around

10
Car-dependent
Walk Score®
21
Minimal transit
Transit Score®
41
Somewhat bikeable
Bike Score®
The area around 5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597 is highly car dependent. Few, if any, services and amenities are nearby, making a car essential for running errands. The area has minimal public transportation, with very few options available for commuting. 5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597 is in a somewhat bikeable area, with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use. 
Walkability data provided by Walk Score®

Plan your commute

  • Middleton's city center
    8 min
    19 min
    59 min
Commute times provided by Walk Score® Travel Time.

See what’s nearby

Eagle's Wing Child Care
Childcare • 2.96 mi
NR
Bernie's Place
Childcare • 3.15 mi
NR
Great Beginnings
Childcare • 4.49 mi
NR
The Playing Field
Childcare • 4.53 mi
NR
The Seventeenth Radish
Childcare • 4.68 mi
NR
Koala T Kare Childcare
Childcare • 4.74 mi
NR
Community Coordinated Child Care
Childcare • 4.82 mi
NR
Moppet Play House
Childcare • 4.83 mi
NR
Northside Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 345 students • 1.74 mi
5/10
Sauk Trail Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 407 students • 2.04 mi
4/10
Westside Christian School
Private • PK-8 • 141 students • 2.35 mi
NR
Elm Lawn Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 355 students • 2.80 mi
8/10
Shorewood Hills Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 381 students • 3.29 mi
9/10
Crestwood Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 272 students • 3.33 mi
4/10
Charis Classical Academy
Private • PK, K-5 • 21 students • 3.61 mi
NR
St Peter Catholic School
Private • PK-5 • 72 students • 3.72 mi
NR
Peace Thru Christ Lutheran School
Private • 1-7 • 2 students • 0.86 mi
NR
Northside Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 345 students • 1.74 mi
5/10
Sauk Trail Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 407 students • 2.04 mi
4/10
Kromrey Middle School
Public • 5-8 • 1191 students • 2.08 mi
7/10
Westside Christian School
Private • PK-8 • 141 students • 2.35 mi
NR
21st Century Eschool
Charter • K-12 • 4 students • 2.45 mi
NR
Elm Lawn Elementary School
Public • PK, K-4 • 355 students • 2.80 mi
8/10
Shorewood Hills Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 381 students • 3.29 mi
9/10
Peace Thru Christ Lutheran School
Private • 1-7 • 2 students • 0.86 mi
NR
Kromrey Middle School
Public • 5-8 • 1191 students • 2.08 mi
7/10
Westside Christian School
Private • PK-8 • 141 students • 2.35 mi
NR
21st Century Eschool
Charter • K-12 • 4 students • 2.45 mi
NR
Spring Harbor Middle School
Public • 6-8 • 263 students • 2.90 mi
5/10
Charis Classical Academy
Private • K-11 • 137 students • 3.61 mi
NR
St Ambrose Academy
Private • 6-12 • 112 students • 3.67 mi
NR
Mendota Mental Health Institution
Public • PK, K-12 • 25 students • 3.73 mi
NR
Clark Street Community School
Charter • 9-12 • 100 students • 2.43 mi
4/10
Middleton High School
Public • 9-12 • 2309 students • 2.43 mi
8/10
21st Century Eschool
Charter • K-12 • 4 students • 2.45 mi
NR
Charis Classical Academy
Private • K-11 • 137 students • 3.61 mi
NR
St Ambrose Academy
Private • 6-12 • 112 students • 3.67 mi
NR
Mendota Mental Health Institution
Public • PK, K-12 • 25 students • 3.73 mi
NR
Walbridge School
Private • 4-12 • 15 students • 3.73 mi
NR
Central Wisconsin Center
Public • PK, K-12 • 1 students • 4.00 mi
NR
University of Wisconsin-Madison
College • 4.23 mi
NR
Charmany Instructional Facility
College • 4.41 mi
NR
Edgewood College
College • 5.11 mi
NR
Lakeland University-Madison Center
College • 5.88 mi
NR
Madison College-Commercial Avenue Education Center
College • 5.90 mi
NR
Madison Area Technical College-South Campus
College • 6.83 mi
NR
Madison Area Technical College-Truax Campus
College • 7.00 mi
NR
Madison Area Technical College-Goodman South Campus
College • 7.02 mi
NR
South Ridge & County Highway Q (WB)
Bus
0.70 mi
South Ridge & Valley Ridge (SB)
Bus
0.76 mi
Valley Ridge & Century (SB)
Bus
0.90 mi
Century & Valley Ridge (EB)
Bus
0.90 mi
Century & Baskerville (EB)
Bus
1.16 mi
Century & Baskerville (WB)
Bus
1.17 mi
Century & Marina (EB)
Bus
1.40 mi
Century & Marina (WB)
Bus
1.40 mi
Middleton Municipal Airport - Morey Field
Airport
3.10 mi
Waunakee Airport
Airport
4.03 mi
Dane County Regional Airport
Airport
6.84 mi
Dane Airport
Airport
6.91 mi
Verona Airport
Airport
9.47 mi
South Ridge & County Highway Q (WB)
Bus
0.70 mi
South Ridge & Valley Ridge (SB)
Bus
0.76 mi
Valley Ridge & Century (SB)
Bus
0.90 mi
Century & Valley Ridge (EB)
Bus
0.90 mi
Century & Baskerville (EB)
Bus
1.16 mi
Century & Baskerville (WB)
Bus
1.17 mi
Century & Marina (EB)
Bus
1.40 mi
Century & Marina (WB)
Bus
1.40 mi
Captain Bill's
Restaurant
1.49 mi
McDonald's
Food
1.57 mi
Starbucks
Restaurant
1.59 mi
Grand China
Food
1.60 mi
Yuremi Fruiteria y Taqueria
Food
1.61 mi
C's
Restaurant
1.62 mi
Mid Town Pub
Drinks
1.68 mi
Cocina Real
Restaurant
1.69 mi
Mid Town Pub
Drinks
1.68 mi
Bristled Boar Saloon
Drinks
1.77 mi
Club Tavern
Drinks
2.18 mi
The Sport Bowl
Drinks
2.34 mi
The Free House Pub
Drinks
2.80 mi
The Village Green
Drinks
2.82 mi
Capital Brewery Bier Garten
Drinks
3.00 mi
Willows Tavern
Drinks
3.24 mi
McDonald's
Food
1.57 mi
Grand China
Food
1.60 mi
Yuremi Fruiteria y Taqueria
Food
1.61 mi
Burger King
Food
2.11 mi
Papa John's
Food
2.27 mi
Chocolate Shoppe
Food
2.33 mi
Milio's
Food
2.36 mi
Culver's
Food
2.36 mi
Captain Bill's
Restaurant
1.49 mi
Starbucks
Restaurant
1.59 mi
C's
Restaurant
1.62 mi
Cocina Real
Restaurant
1.69 mi
Prairie Cafe and Bakery
Restaurant
1.75 mi
Lupe's Taqueria
Restaurant
1.77 mi
1847 at the Stamm House
Restaurant
1.77 mi
Pizza Brutta
Restaurant
1.77 mi
Kwik Trip
Grocery store
0.73 mi
Dollar General
Shopping
0.86 mi
Goodwill
Shopping
1.58 mi
Abarrotes Yuremi
Grocery store
1.60 mi
Neil's Liquor
Shopping
1.65 mi
Puttin on the Ritz
Shopping
1.67 mi
Dollar Tree
Shopping
1.68 mi
Gino's Deli
Shopping
1.71 mi
Kwik Trip
Grocery store
0.73 mi
Abarrotes Yuremi
Grocery store
1.60 mi
Kwik Trip
Grocery store
1.73 mi
Pick 'n Save
Grocery store
1.74 mi
Citgo
Grocery store
2.12 mi
Kwik Trip
Grocery store
2.16 mi
Willy Street Co-Op
Grocery store
2.37 mi
Clasen's European Bakery
Grocery store
2.40 mi
Dollar General
Shopping
0.86 mi
Goodwill
Shopping
1.58 mi
Neil's Liquor
Shopping
1.65 mi
Puttin on the Ritz
Shopping
1.67 mi
Dollar Tree
Shopping
1.68 mi
Gino's Deli
Shopping
1.71 mi
Best Cleaners
Shopping
1.78 mi
U.S. Cellular
Shopping
1.79 mi
Kwik Trip
Automotive
0.73 mi
Peace Thru Christ Lutheran School
Place of worship
0.86 mi
Park Office
Public service
0.95 mi
Small Dog Area
Pet care
1.25 mi
Middleton Dog Exercise Area
Pet care
1.40 mi
CVS Pharmacy
Healthcare
1.54 mi
Killian Dental Center/Midwest Dental
Healthcare
1.65 mi
H&R Block
Other
1.67 mi
Kwik Trip
Automotive
0.73 mi
Kwik Trip
Automotive
1.72 mi
Citgo
Automotive
2.13 mi
Marshall Boats
Automotive
2.15 mi
Kwik Trip
Automotive
2.16 mi
Middleton Park and Ride
Automotive
2.16 mi
Magic Wash Car Wash
Automotive
2.21 mi
BP
Automotive
2.26 mi
CVS Pharmacy
Healthcare
1.54 mi
Killian Dental Center/Midwest Dental
Healthcare
1.65 mi
Walgreens
Healthcare
2.18 mi
The Villa at Middleton Village
Healthcare
2.64 mi
Meriter Middleton Clinic
Healthcare
2.90 mi
First Choice Dental
Healthcare
2.91 mi
Miramont Behavioral Health
Healthcare
3.05 mi
Forward Dental
Healthcare
3.14 mi
Towneplace Suites
Hotel
2.73 mi
Courtyard
Hotel
2.94 mi
Staybridge Suites
Hotel
2.95 mi
Country Inn & Suites
Hotel
3.01 mi
Holiday Inn Express
Hotel
3.31 mi
Fairfield Inn
Hotel
3.47 mi
Hilton Garden Inn
Hotel
3.47 mi
SpringHill Suites
Hotel
3.50 mi
H&R Block
Other
1.67 mi
Dero
Other
1.69 mi
Bike Fixtation
Other
2.13 mi
American Family Insurance
Other
2.28 mi
State Farm
Other
2.37 mi
Dero
Other
2.71 mi
McGourn and Kaplan
Other
2.77 mi
RepairSTAN
Other
3.45 mi
Majestic Nails
Personal care
1.77 mi
Supercuts
Personal care
1.78 mi
Artisan Hair Studio
Personal care
2.38 mi
Gene's Professional Hair Care
Personal care
2.80 mi
Marilynn's Salon
Personal care
2.80 mi
Mitz
Personal care
2.85 mi
Elements Massage
Personal care
2.89 mi
Shine Salons
Personal care
2.97 mi
Small Dog Area
Pet care
1.25 mi
Middleton Dog Exercise Area
Pet care
1.40 mi
And Dogs Too
Pet care
1.72 mi
Middleton Veterinary Hospital
Pet care
2.37 mi
Tabby & Jack's
Pet care
2.41 mi
All Pets Veterinary Clinic
Pet care
3.12 mi
Spring Harbor Animal Hospital
Pet care
3.19 mi
Animart
Pet care
3.26 mi
Peace Thru Christ Lutheran School
Place of worship
0.86 mi
Gateway Community Church
Place of worship
1.71 mi
Gurudwara Shaibji
Place of worship
1.80 mi
St. Andrew Lutheran Church
Place of worship
2.34 mi
St Dunstan's Episcopal Church
Place of worship
2.47 mi
Asbury United Methodist Church
Place of worship
2.51 mi
Saint Bernard Catholic Church
Place of worship
2.70 mi
Saint Luke's Lutheran Church
Place of worship
2.73 mi
Park Office
Public service
0.95 mi
UW Credit Union
Public service
1.80 mi
Park Office
Public service
1.84 mi
Middleton Community Bank
Public service
2.17 mi
Wells Fargo
Public service
2.22 mi
Middleton Police Department
Public service
2.29 mi
The UPS Store
Public service
2.39 mi
Middleton City Hall
Public service
2.73 mi
Harbor Athletic Club
Sports
1.51 mi
Harbor Athletic Club
Sports
1.59 mi
Princeton Club Xpress
Sports
1.71 mi
Walter R. Bauman Aquatic Center
Sports
2.24 mi
Middleton Performing Arts Center
Entertainment
2.44 mi
Capital City Theatre
Entertainment
2.44 mi
Little Free Library
Entertainment
2.58 mi
Middleton Historical Society Museum
Entertainment
2.72 mi
Middleton Performing Arts Center
Entertainment
2.44 mi
Capital City Theatre
Entertainment
2.44 mi
Little Free Library
Entertainment
2.58 mi
Middleton Historical Society Museum
Entertainment
2.72 mi
Little Free Library
Entertainment
2.73 mi
Little Free Library
Entertainment
2.75 mi
Middleton Public Library
Entertainment
2.76 mi
National Mustard Museum
Entertainment
2.81 mi
Harbor Athletic Club
Sports
1.51 mi
Harbor Athletic Club
Sports
1.59 mi
Princeton Club Xpress
Sports
1.71 mi
Walter R. Bauman Aquatic Center
Sports
2.24 mi
REFORMadison
Sports
2.83 mi
Peter Kraus Fitness
Sports
2.87 mi
The Little Gym
Sports
2.90 mi
Body Mechanix
Sports
2.97 mi

Average utility cost in Wisconsin

In Wisconsin, renters typically spend around $312 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $18 for sewer to $115 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.

Electricity grafic icon
Electricity
$115
Gas grafic icon
Gas
$70
Water grafic icon
Water
$20
Sewer grafic icon
Sewer
$18
Cable grafic icon
Cable
$59
Internet grafic icon
Internet
$30

Community reviews
How are these reviews collected?
5 (2 reviews)

What other renters say:

Verified Resident
Apr 13, 2026 • Olayemi O.
Best place ever. So peaceful and serene
Verified Resident
Jul 25, 2024 • Bev L.
I enjoy living at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay. Great apartment, nice neifgbors, quiet, great amenities and staff.

What about a house for the same budget?

Still looking? Here's more!

FAQs about Paragon Place at Bishops Bay

When was this property’s information last updated?

The details for Paragon Place at Bishops Bay were last updated 1 hour ago.

What floor plans are available?

Paragon Place at Bishops Bay offers the following floor plan options: one-bedroom, two-bedroom.

Is Paragon Place at Bishops Bay pet-friendly?

Yes, pets are welcome at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay.
Here are the details:
  • Pet policy - Cats allowed
    Pet limit 2 allowed. $50 for first pet per month. $40 for 2nd pet per month. The 1st and 2nd floors are pet-friendly. The 3rd floor is pet-free.
  • Pet policy - Dogs allowed
    Pet limit 2 allowed. $50 for first pet per month. $40 for 2nd pet per month. The 1st and 2nd floors are pet-friendly. The 3rd floor is pet-free.
Pets allowed. Maximum 2 pets per apartment. The 1st and 2nd floors are pet-friendly. The 3rd floor is pet-free. Some breed restrictions apply for dogs. No weight limit for dogs. Exotic pets are not permitted. For more information about the Paragon Place Pet-Friendly Policy and requirements, please inquire within.

Do units at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay come with air conditioning?

Yes, units at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay come with air conditioning.

Does Paragon Place at Bishops Bay have a pool?

Yes, Paragon Place at Bishops Bay comes with a pool.

Do units at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay come with a garage?

Yes, Paragon Place at Bishops Bay features garages.

Is there a fitness center/gym available at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay?

Yes, Paragon Place at Bishops Bay includes a gym.

What neighborhood is this property in?

5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597 is in North Lake.

What are popular apartment communities in North Lake?

Popular apartment communities in North Lake include: Lake 61, The Aviary at Middleton Market, Market West Apartments, The Waverly, The West Edge.

How far is Paragon Place at Bishops Bay from the city center?

Paragon Place at Bishops Bay is approximately 8 minutes away by car from the city center.

What's the best way to get around the area?

The area around 5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597 is highly car dependent. Few, if any, services and amenities are nearby, making a car essential for running errands. The area has minimal public transportation, with very few options available for commuting. 5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597 is in a somewhat bikeable area, with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use. 

What childcare centers are close by?

Nearby childcare centers include Eagle's Wing Child Care, Bernie's Place, Great Beginnings.

What schools are close by?

Nearby schools include Peace Thru Christ Lutheran School, Northside Elementary School, Sauk Trail Elementary School.

What colleges are close by?

Nearby colleges include University of Wisconsin-Madison, Charmany Instructional Facility, Edgewood College.

What are the price ranges for the units in this building?

Prices in Paragon Place at Bishops Bay are at:
  • $2,112-$2,371 for two-bedroom units

How does this rent compare with rents in Middleton?

Rent in Middleton averages at $1,670, compared to prices of $2,112-$2,371 /mo at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay.

Are there any other apartments around for the same amount?

Here are some apartment communities near 5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, WI, 53597 with similar rents: Lake 61, The Aviary at Middleton Market, Market West Apartments, The Waverly, The West Edge, Preserve West, Two Points Crossing, EO Madison Yards, Harbour Town, Park Regent Apartments.

Does the rent at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay include utilities?

No, utilities are not included in the rent at Paragon Place at Bishops Bay. Tenants are typically responsible for all utilities.

Can I see this property online somehow?

Yes, Paragon Place at Bishops Bay offers online viewing through a video walkthrough. You'll find it in the photo gallery.

Can I tour Paragon Place at Bishops Bay?

Yes, you can schedule a tour by using the options available on this page. Business hours are as follows:
Monday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Are there any reviews or ratings related to Paragon Place at Bishops Bay or its management company?

Yes, you’ll find reviews for Paragon Place at Bishops Bay above—see what past and current residents have to say about living here.

Cast a wider net