Skip to main content

Greater Monticello, Thompson - Mamakating, NY houses for rent

No luck – your dream rental is playing hard to get

If your perfect match isn’t here, it might be time to compromise… just a little!

Try a different place

Get to know Greater Monticello, Thompson - Mamakating, NY

See what’s nearby

Benjamin Cosor Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 810 students
3/10
George L Cooke School
Public • PK, K-2 • 592 students
NR
Talmud Torah Imrei Burech
Private • PK-11 • 236 students
NR
Popeyes
Food
Burger King
Food
Dunkin'
Food
McDonald's
Food
Pops Sweet Shoppe
Food
Sportsbook 360
Drinks
Butterfly Beach Pool Bar
Drinks
Harvey's Wallbanger
Drinks
Empire Lounge
Drinks
Sportsbook 360
Drinks
Butterfly Beach Pool Bar
Drinks
Harvey's Wallbanger
Drinks
Empire Lounge
Drinks
Bar Mez
Drinks
Popeyes
Food
Burger King
Food
Dunkin'
Food
McDonald's
Food
Pops Sweet Shoppe
Food
The Highline
Restaurant
Cellaio
Restaurant
Dos Gatos Cantina
Restaurant
RW Food Hall
Restaurant
Bixby’s Derby
Restaurant
24/7 Bistro
Restaurant
Lotus
Restaurant
Good Friends
Restaurant
Eat. Eat. Eat.
Restaurant
Chevrolet
Shopping
Staples
Shopping
Ford
Shopping
Walmart Supercenter
Grocery store
ShopRite
Grocery store
Walmart Supercenter
Grocery store
ShopRite
Grocery store
Chevrolet
Shopping
Staples
Shopping
Ford
Shopping
Wolf Brook Road South Parking Lot
Automotive
ChargePoint
Automotive
Tesla Supercharger
Automotive
Wolf Brook Road North Parking Lot
Automotive
Town of Thompson
Public service
Thompson Town Hall
Public service
Sullivan County Sheriff's Office
Public service
Sullivan County Jail
Public service
Garnet Health Medical Center - Catskills, Harris Campus
Healthcare
Wolf Brook Road South Parking Lot
Automotive
ChargePoint
Automotive
Tesla Supercharger
Automotive
Wolf Brook Road North Parking Lot
Automotive
Garnet Health Medical Center - Catskills, Harris Campus
Healthcare
Kartrite Resort Hotel
Hotel
Hampton Inn
Hotel
South Lodge
Hotel
North Lodge
Hotel
The Alder at Resorts World Catskills
Hotel
Resorts World Catskills Hotel
Hotel
Awana Spa
Personal care
Town of Thompson
Public service
Thompson Town Hall
Public service
Sullivan County Sheriff's Office
Public service
Sullivan County Jail
Public service
RW Epicenter
Entertainment
Resorts World Catskills
Entertainment
Holiday Mountain Ski and Fun Park
Sports
Monticello Motor Club
Sports
Monticello Raceway
Sports
RW Epicenter
Entertainment
Resorts World Catskills
Entertainment
Holiday Mountain Ski and Fun Park
Sports
Monticello Motor Club
Sports
Monticello Raceway
Sports

Average rent in Monticello

In Monticello, the average rent is $1,387 per month, with the average rental size around 687 square feet. Most renters here pay between $1,000 - $1,500, making it the most common rent bracket in the area.

Average rent
$1,387/month
Average rental size
687 sqft
Rent ranges
Under $1,000
8.8%
$1,001 - $1,500
56.4%
$1,501 - $2,000
34.8%
$2,001 - $2,500
0%
$2,501 - $3,000
0%
Over $3,000
0%
Rent data provided by Yardi® Matrix.
Curious how rent prices changed over time? Dive deeper into Monticello's rent trends

Average utility cost in New York

In New York, renters typically spend around $470 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for internet to $148 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.

Electricity grafic icon
Electricity
$148
Gas grafic icon
Gas
$144
Water grafic icon
Water
$34
Sewer grafic icon
Sewer
$55
Cable grafic icon
Cable
$59
Internet grafic icon
Internet
$30

Think bigger. Search wider

Find houses for rent near you – Start your search on Point2Homes

Looking for a house to rent nearby? Point2Homes makes it easy to explore updated listings for single-family homes and detached rentals near your current location. Whether you're searching for a cozy house, a spacious family home, or a pet-friendly property with a backyard, we’ve got you covered.

Browse houses for rent by price, number of bedrooms, amenities, and neighborhood, right from your phone or desktop. You can compare square footage, locations, and resident insights to make the best decision. Expand your search to nearby suburbs, cities, or even across the U.S. if you're ready for a bigger move.

Wherever you're headed, the right rental home is waiting. Let Point2Homes help you find it quickly and easily.

0-0-nhood