Skip to main content

From $1,600/mo

(2)

5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235

5357 Traditions Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235

3 beds 1.5 baths 1,144 sqft

All about this rental

Quick overview

Type:
House
Neighborhood:
Traditions
ZIP code:
46235
Status:
Active
Last checked:
1 hour ago

Find your perfect layout

Perks of living here

In-house comforts

  • Air Conditioning
  • Dishwasher
  • Electronic Thermostat
  • Fence
  • Patio/Balcony

Ready to see it in person?

Fees & policies

General fees

Security deposit:
$1,600
Application fees:
$55
There may be additional unit-specific fees.
The fees are estimates and actual amounts may vary. Pricing and availability are subject to change. For details, .

Contact info
FKH-FirstKey Homes
Property listed in the Yardi Rental ILS Network (RentCafe.com & Point2Homes.com).

Get to know the area

Know your way around

4
Car-dependent
Walk Score®
N/A
No data
Transit Score®
31
Somewhat bikeable
Bike Score®
The area around 5357 Traditions Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235 is highly car dependent. Few, if any, services and amenities are nearby, making a car essential for running errands. 5357 Traditions Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235 is in a somewhat bikeable area, with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use. 
Walkability data provided by Walk Score®

Plan your commute

  • Lawrence's city center
    24 min
Commute times provided by Walk Score® Travel Time.

See what’s nearby

Kelley's Exclusive Child Care
Childcare • 2.95 mi
NR
Beech Babies Childcare Ministries
Childcare • 5.12 mi
NR
Stepping Stones II
Childcare • 5.31 mi
NR
Stepping Stones I
Childcare • 5.32 mi
NR
KidzPointe Academy
Childcare • 5.44 mi
NR
In His Arms Child Care
Childcare • 6.70 mi
NR
Bright Beginnings Learning Academy
Childcare • 7.39 mi
NR
Tyler's Journey Childcare Ministry
Childcare • 7.75 mi
NR
Cornerstone Baptist Academy
Private • PK-12 • 107 students • 1.25 mi
NR
Turning Point Schools
Private • PK-8 • 257 students • 1.45 mi
NR
Forest Glen Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 880 students • 1.57 mi
8/10
Francis Scott Key School 103
Charter • PK, K-6 • 538 students • 1.78 mi
3/10
Early Learning Center
Public • PK, K • 1298 students • 1.98 mi
NR
Charles Warren Fairbanks School 105
Public • PK, K-6 • 313 students • 2.13 mi
3/10
Horizon Christian School
Private • PK-12 • 278 students • 3.07 mi
NR
Horizon Christian School
Private • PK, K-12 • 279 students • 3.07 mi
NR
Indian Creek Elementary School
Public • 1-6 • 707 students • 0.57 mi
4/10
Phalen Virtual Leadership Academy
Charter • K-12 • 350 students • 1.11 mi
2/10
Cornerstone Baptist Academy
Private • PK-12 • 107 students • 1.25 mi
NR
Turning Point Schools
Private • PK-8 • 257 students • 1.45 mi
NR
Fortune Academy
Private • 1-12 • 86 students • 1.52 mi
NR
Forest Glen Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 880 students • 1.57 mi
8/10
Promise Prep
Charter • K-3 • 69 students • 1.60 mi
NR
Winding Ridge Elementary School
Public • 1-6 • 620 students • 1.76 mi
3/10
J & R Phalen Leadership Academy
Charter • 7-8 • 284 students • 1.11 mi
2/10
Phalen Virtual Leadership Academy
Charter • K-12 • 350 students • 1.11 mi
2/10
Cornerstone Baptist Academy
Private • PK-12 • 107 students • 1.25 mi
NR
Fall Creek Valley Middle School
Public • 7-8 • 1351 students • 1.37 mi
4/10
Turning Point Schools
Private • PK-8 • 257 students • 1.45 mi
NR
Fortune Academy
Private • 1-12 • 86 students • 1.52 mi
NR
George and Veronica Phalen Leadership Academy
Charter • K-8 • 239 students • 1.79 mi
4/10
John Marshall Community High School (7-8)
Public • 7-8 • 422 students • 1.85 mi
NR
James and Rosemary Phalen Leadersh
Charter • 9-12 • 474 students • 1.11 mi
1/10
Phalen Virtual Leadership Academy
Charter • K-12 • 350 students • 1.11 mi
2/10
Cornerstone Baptist Academy
Private • PK-12 • 107 students • 1.25 mi
NR
Fortune Academy
Private • 1-12 • 86 students • 1.52 mi
NR
John Marshall Community High School (9-12)
Public • 9-12 • 494 students • 1.73 mi
NR
Indianapolis Lighthouse East
Charter • 7-12 • 363 students • 2.69 mi
NR
Lawrence Central High School
Public • 9-12 • 2317 students • 2.77 mi
3/10
Horizon Christian School
Private • PK-12 • 278 students • 3.07 mi
NR
Vet Tech Institute
College • 3.78 mi
NR
International Business College
College • 3.79 mi
NR
Ivy Tech Community College
College • 9.73 mi
NR
Butler University
College • 9.91 mi
NR
Charnock and 33rd
Bus
2.60 mi
46th and Shadeland IB
Bus
3.32 mi
46th and Shadeland Ave OB
Bus
3.36 mi
46th and Brookhaven Dr IB
Bus
3.59 mi
46th and Brookhaven Dr OB
Bus
3.59 mi
Mitthoefer Rd and 21st St
Bus
3.73 mi
46th and Kitley OB
Bus
3.75 mi
21st St & Mitthoeffer Rd IB
Bus
3.77 mi
Indianapolis Regional Airport
Airport
4.65 mi
Indianapolis Metropolitan Airport
Airport
6.72 mi
Post-Aire Airport
Airport
7.11 mi
Morris Airport
Airport
9.22 mi
Charnock and 33rd
Bus
2.60 mi
46th and Shadeland IB
Bus
3.32 mi
46th and Shadeland Ave OB
Bus
3.36 mi
46th and Brookhaven Dr IB
Bus
3.59 mi
46th and Brookhaven Dr OB
Bus
3.59 mi
Mitthoefer Rd and 21st St
Bus
3.73 mi
46th and Kitley OB
Bus
3.75 mi
21st St & Mitthoeffer Rd IB
Bus
3.77 mi
Fishers Train Station
Train
7.51 mi
Buffalo Wild Wings
Restaurant
0.57 mi
Subway
Food
1.10 mi
Steak 'n Shake
Food
1.16 mi
IHOP
Restaurant
1.18 mi
Cafe Audrey
Restaurant
1.24 mi
Fitzgerald's Lunch House
Restaurant
1.25 mi
Culver's
Food
1.27 mi
La Hacienda
Restaurant
1.49 mi
Murphy's Craft House
Drinks
3.77 mi
10th Street Pub
Drinks
4.72 mi
Sahm's Bar and Grill
Drinks
5.68 mi
Sun King Brewery
Drinks
5.69 mi
The Free Spirit
Drinks
5.77 mi
Time Out Lounge
Drinks
5.96 mi
Hilltop Tavern
Drinks
6.11 mi
Ale Emporium
Drinks
6.28 mi
Subway
Food
1.10 mi
Steak 'n Shake
Food
1.16 mi
Culver's
Food
1.27 mi
Hardee's
Food
2.40 mi
McDonald's
Food
3.33 mi
Taco Bell
Food
3.42 mi
Wendy's
Food
3.59 mi
Steak 'n Shake
Food
3.62 mi
Buffalo Wild Wings
Restaurant
0.57 mi
IHOP
Restaurant
1.18 mi
Cafe Audrey
Restaurant
1.24 mi
Fitzgerald's Lunch House
Restaurant
1.25 mi
La Hacienda
Restaurant
1.49 mi
Bando
Restaurant
2.33 mi
Heidelberg Cafe
Restaurant
2.72 mi
Pizza Hut
Restaurant
3.20 mi
Speedway
Grocery store
0.36 mi
Dollar General
Shopping
0.42 mi
Walmart Supercenter
Grocery store
0.72 mi
Kohl's
Shopping
1.04 mi
Ryan Consulting Group
Shopping
1.08 mi
Kroger
Grocery store
1.11 mi
Crown Autos
Shopping
1.95 mi
Metro by T-Mobile
Shopping
2.33 mi
Speedway
Grocery store
0.36 mi
Walmart Supercenter
Grocery store
0.72 mi
Kroger
Grocery store
1.11 mi
Speedway
Grocery store
3.20 mi
Kroger
Grocery store
3.23 mi
Shadland Mobil
Grocery store
3.25 mi
Speedway
Grocery store
3.26 mi
BP Shop
Grocery store
3.31 mi
Dollar General
Shopping
0.42 mi
Kohl's
Shopping
1.04 mi
Ryan Consulting Group
Shopping
1.08 mi
Crown Autos
Shopping
1.95 mi
Metro by T-Mobile
Shopping
2.33 mi
Goodwill
Shopping
2.47 mi
MacExperience
Shopping
2.92 mi
Walgreens
Shopping
3.23 mi
Speedway
Automotive
0.35 mi
K & K Automotive Inc.
Automotive
0.73 mi
Murphy USA
Automotive
0.79 mi
Baymont Indianapolis Northeast
Hotel
0.89 mi
Dr. J Pediatric Dentistry
Healthcare
0.89 mi
BP / Ricker's
Automotive
1.05 mi
Tru by Hilton Indianapolis-Lawrence
Hotel
1.14 mi
Bells Chapel Church of God
Place of worship
1.23 mi
Speedway
Automotive
0.35 mi
K & K Automotive Inc.
Automotive
0.73 mi
Murphy USA
Automotive
0.79 mi
BP / Ricker's
Automotive
1.05 mi
Neuwell Auto
Automotive
1.33 mi
Tour Lawrence
Automotive
1.47 mi
Lawrence Creek Trailhead Parking
Automotive
2.26 mi
Exxon
Automotive
2.80 mi
Dr. J Pediatric Dentistry
Healthcare
0.89 mi
CVS Pharmacy
Healthcare
1.30 mi
Options Behavioral Health System
Healthcare
3.08 mi
Walgreens
Healthcare
3.23 mi
Mitthoeffer Family Dental
Healthcare
3.57 mi
Geist Dental Care
Healthcare
3.76 mi
Geist Orthodontics
Healthcare
3.98 mi
CVS Pharmacy
Healthcare
4.03 mi
Baymont Indianapolis Northeast
Hotel
0.89 mi
Tru by Hilton Indianapolis-Lawrence
Hotel
1.14 mi
Fort Harrison State Park Inn
Hotel
1.50 mi
La Quinta Inn Indianapolis East-Post Drive
Hotel
3.66 mi
Shadeland Inn
Hotel
3.77 mi
InTown Suites Extended Stay Indianapolis IN - Post Drive
Hotel
3.81 mi
Days Inn by Wyndham Indianapolis East Post Road
Hotel
3.89 mi
Country Hearth Inn Indianapolis
Hotel
3.97 mi
WorkOne
Other
3.36 mi
AAA Braeburn Village
Other
4.28 mi
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Other
4.87 mi
Hartranft Appraisal Service
Other
5.17 mi
Brian Ciesil American Family Insurance
Other
5.47 mi
Chuck Schoolcraft - State Farm Insurance Agent
Other
5.58 mi
American Family Insurance
Other
5.67 mi
Colbert/Ball Tax Services
Other
5.73 mi
Marshall Beauty
Personal care
2.35 mi
K's Nails
Personal care
3.73 mi
Great Clips
Personal care
3.73 mi
Great Clips
Personal care
3.74 mi
Rest Well Relaxation
Personal care
4.82 mi
Great Clips
Personal care
4.82 mi
Coco Nails
Personal care
4.88 mi
Mane Street
Personal care
4.89 mi
Noah's Caring Hands Animal Hospital at Geist
Pet care
3.18 mi
30th Street Animal Hospital
Pet care
3.22 mi
Speck's
Pet care
3.72 mi
Windermere Animal Hospital
Pet care
5.43 mi
PetSmart
Pet care
5.43 mi
Happiness is Pets.
Pet care
5.66 mi
Log Cabin Animal Hospital
Pet care
6.05 mi
PetSmart
Pet care
6.25 mi
Bells Chapel Church of God
Place of worship
1.23 mi
Lawrence Independent Baptist Church
Place of worship
1.68 mi
Lawrence Church of God
Place of worship
1.72 mi
Asbury United Methodist Church
Place of worship
1.83 mi
New Fellowship Family Church
Place of worship
1.97 mi
Missionary Free Christian Church
Place of worship
2.05 mi
Crossroads Bible Church
Place of worship
2.07 mi
Lawrence Full Gospel Tabernacle
Place of worship
2.14 mi
Indianapolis Fire Station 2
Public service
1.31 mi
Old National Bank
Public service
1.37 mi
Major General Emmett J Bean Center
Public service
1.51 mi
Morris Settles Lawrence Public Safety Building
Public service
2.22 mi
Lawrence Fire Station 1
Public service
2.24 mi
Lawrence Post Office
Public service
2.28 mi
Lawrence Fire Station 3
Public service
2.33 mi
Lawrence Fire Station 2
Public service
2.73 mi
Indianapolis Public Library-Ft Ben Branch
Entertainment
0.98 mi
Benjamin Harrison YMCA
Sports
1.00 mi
Community Association Far Eastside
Entertainment
2.14 mi
Trails End Fire Bowl
Entertainment
3.18 mi
pool
Sports
3.19 mi
tennis
Sports
3.41 mi
basketball
Sports
3.42 mi
pool
Sports
3.48 mi
Indianapolis Public Library-Ft Ben Branch
Entertainment
0.98 mi
Community Association Far Eastside
Entertainment
2.14 mi
Trails End Fire Bowl
Entertainment
3.18 mi
Cumulus Indianapolis
Entertainment
3.79 mi
Warren Branch Indianapolis-Marion County Public Library
Entertainment
3.85 mi
Indiana State Police Museum
Entertainment
4.05 mi
Lawrence Branch - Indianapolis Marion-County Public Library
Entertainment
4.11 mi
Warren Perfoming Arts Center
Entertainment
4.28 mi
Benjamin Harrison YMCA
Sports
1.00 mi
pool
Sports
3.19 mi
tennis
Sports
3.41 mi
basketball
Sports
3.42 mi
pool
Sports
3.48 mi
Jazzercise
Sports
3.71 mi
Warrior Stadium
Sports
4.06 mi
Planet Fitness
Sports
4.06 mi

Average utility cost in Indiana

In Indiana, renters typically spend around $413 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for internet to $129 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.

Electricity grafic icon
Electricity
$129
Gas grafic icon
Gas
$89
Water grafic icon
Water
$37
Sewer grafic icon
Sewer
$69
Cable grafic icon
Cable
$59
Internet grafic icon
Internet
$30

Community reviews
How are these reviews collected?
4.7 (2 reviews)

What other renters say:

Verified Resident
Aug 7, 2025 • Lisa L.
First key homes, takes care of their properties and work with their residents. They are a very professional and reputable company. Thanks First key!
Verified Resident
Oct 16, 2023 • Lisa L.

Still looking? Here's more!

FAQs about 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235

When was the data on this property last updated?

The information for 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235 was last updated 1 hour ago.

What floor plan options are available?

At 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235, there is only one floor plan option, three-plus-bedroom.

Is 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235 pet-friendly?

Yes, 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235 is pet-friendly.

In what neighborhood is this property located?

5357 Traditions Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235 is in Traditions.

What are some of the most popular house rentals in Traditions?

How far is this property from the city center?

5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235 is approximately 24 minutes away by car from the city center.

How do people usually get around the area?

The area around 5357 Traditions Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235 is highly car dependent. Few, if any, services and amenities are nearby, making a car essential for running errands. 5357 Traditions Drive, Indianapolis, IN, 46235 is in a somewhat bikeable area, with minimal cycling infrastructure available for use. 

What childcare centers are nearby?

Here are some nearby childcare centers: Kelley's Exclusive Child Care, Beech Babies Childcare Ministries, Stepping Stones II.

What schools are nearby?

Here are some nearby schools: Indian Creek Elementary School, Phalen Virtual Leadership Academy, J & R Phalen Leadership Academy.

What colleges are nearby?

Here are some nearby colleges: Vet Tech Institute, International Business College, Ivy Tech Community College.

How does this rent compare with rents in Lawrence?

Rent in Lawrence averages at $1,195, compared to starting prices of $1,600 /mo at 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235.

Are there any house rentals around for the same amount?

Are utilities included in the rent at 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235?

Utilities are not part of the rent at 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235; tenants are responsible for covering them.

Are there any reviews or ratings for this property or its management company?

Yes, you’ll find reviews for 5357 Traditions Drive Indianapolis, IN 46235 above. See what past and current residents have to say about living here.

Cast a wider net