Skip to main content
Location
Price
$
-
$
Beds & baths
Filters
Availability & specials
Lease options
Property type
Pet policy
Home size
-
Lot size
-
Year built
-
Amenities
Property rating

Middle Island, NY apartments for rent

5 apartments for rent in Middle Island, NY, from 2 communities.

36
Available now
Middle Island apartment for rent - a large living room with couches and a fireplace
$3,099-$3,959 /mo

Stonegate

Middle Island, NY, 11953

1-3 beds 1-2 baths 747-1,369 sqft
View details
63
Rent specials
Middle Island apartment for rent - A living room with a couch, chairs, and a table with a sign that says "avanath.".
Ask for pricing

Eagle View Court 55+ Community

175 Robin Drive, Middle Island, NY, 11953

1-2 beds 1-1.5 baths 800-1,140 sqft
View details

Look beyond, explore listings nearby!

Apartments within a 30-mile radius from your location

38
Rent specials Available now
Ridge apartment for rent - a living room with a couch and a coffee table
$2,099-$2,708 /mo

Brookwood at Ridge

100 Village Drive, Ridge, NY, 11961

1-3 beds 1-1.5 baths 636-1,300 sqft
View details
22
Rent specials Available now
Coram apartment for rent - a kitchen with black appliances and a black refrigerator
$2,060-$2,675 /mo

Oakview Apartments

1 Homestead Drive, Coram, NY, 11727

Studio-3 beds 1-2 baths 394-1,023 sqft
View details
19
Available now Aerial view
Holbrook apartment for rent - a kitchen with wooden cabinets and a white refrigerator
From $2,715 /mo

Brookwood at Holbrook

835 Broadway Avenue, Holbrook, NY, 11741

1-2 beds 1 bath 650-870 sqft
View details
8
Rent specials Available now
Patchogue apartment for rent - a large living room with a pool table and chairs
$3,250-$3,400 /mo

Sutton Landing at Patchogue

1000 Sutton Court, Patchogue, NY, 11772

2 beds 2 baths 1,060-1,109 sqft
View details
26
Available now
Ronkonkoma apartment for rent - A modern living room with a dining table and chairs.
$2,817-$3,702 /mo

Alston at Station Yards

1000 Mill Road, Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

Studio-3 beds 1-2 baths 494-2,056 sqft
View details
18
East Patchogue apartment for rent - A living room with green chairs and a painting on the wall.
Ask for pricing

The Grove Apartments

400 East Main Street, East Patchogue, NY, 11937

1-3 beds 1 bath
View details
18
Available now Aerial view
Bay Shore apartment for rent - a kitchen with white cabinets and a stove and a sink
From $2,171 /mo

Brookwood at Bay Shore

99 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Studio-2 beds 1 bath 400-670 sqft
View details
13
Available now Aerial view
Islip apartment for rent - a kitchen with a stove and a sink and a window
From $2,774 /mo

Brookwood at Islip

29 Buffalo Avenue, Islip, NY, 11751

1-2 beds 1 bath 820-950 sqft
View details
17
Available now Aerial view
Sayville apartment for rent - a kitchen with a stove and a refrigerator
From $2,769 /mo

Brookwood at Sayville

14 Easy Street, Sayville, NY, 11782

1-2 beds 1 bath 650-950 sqft
View details
16
Aerial view
Oakdale apartment for rent - a small kitchen with a sink and a dishwasher
Ask for pricing

Brookwood at Oakdale 55+

100 Patricia Court, Oakdale, NY, 11769

1 bed 1 bath
View details
46
Available now Aerial view
East Moriches apartment for rent - A living room with a white couch and a television.
$2,800-$3,500 /mo

Walden Pond At East Moriches

1 Clubhouse Way, East Moriches, NY, 11940

1-2 beds 1-2 baths 975-1,276 sqft
View details
15
Rent specials Available now
Ronkonkoma apartment for rent - a living room with a couch and a television
$2,213-$4,559 /mo

Colony Park

500 Peconic St, Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779

Studio-2 beds 1 bath 538-1,075 sqft
View details
103
Available now
Hauppauge apartment for rent - A large, modern living room with a dark rug and a large chandelier.
$4,200-$5,180 /mo

Carlow

1721 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY, 11788

1-3 beds 1.5-2.5 baths 935-1,755 sqft
View details
41
Available now
Bay Shore apartment for rent - a living room with a large group of windows and a table and chairs
$2,622-$6,352 /mo

Shoregate

143 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Studio-3 beds 1-2.5 baths 540-1,638 sqft
View details
7
Available now
Commack apartment for rent - a living room with a couch and a table
$5,995-$6,100 /mo

Sutton Landing at Commack

200 Sutton Landing Court, Commack, NY, 11725

2 beds 2.5 baths 1,515-1,876 sqft
View details
1
Available now
Bay Shore apartment for rent - an architectural rendering of a large white house on a street
$2,450-$2,800 /mo

Lofts on Ocean

6 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Studio-1 bed 1 bath 505-1,000 sqft
View details
1
Commack apartment for rent - an empty intersection with a shopping center and a parking lot
Ask for pricing

6333 JERICHO TURNPIKE

COMMACK, NY, 11725

Studio 810-2,600 sqft
View details
9
Available now Aerial view
Norwalk apartment for rent - a living room with a black leather couch and a coffee table
$2,391-$5,641 /mo

Shirt Factory Lofts and The Platform

1 Chestnut St., Norwalk, CT, 06854

Studio-3 beds 1-2 baths 440-1,620 sqft
View details
24
Rent specials Available now
Milford apartment for rent - A large, elegant living room with a dark blue sofa and a chandelier.
$2,048-$5,638 /mo

Merion Milford Apartment Homes

1 Avalon Drive, Milford, CT, 06460

1-2 beds 1-2 baths 682-1,208 sqft
View details
61
Rent specials Available now
New Haven apartment for rent - A modern living room with a black coffee table and a white sculpture on it.
$1,905-$4,035 /mo

The Anthem at Square 10

20 George Street, New Haven, CT, 06510

Studio-2 beds 1-2 baths 373-1,259 sqft
View details
18
Rent specials Available now
Stratford apartment for rent - a living room with a couch and a table
$2,381-$5,567 /mo

Merion Stratford Apartment Homes

1000 Avalon Way, Stratford, CT, 06614

1-3 beds 1-2 baths 792-1,508 sqft
View details
40
Rent specials Available now
Norwalk apartment for rent - a living room with a large window and a couch
$2,530-$4,450 /mo

Sono Central

10 Monroe Street, Norwalk, CT, 06854

Studio-2 beds 1-2 baths 534-1,216 sqft
View details
22
Available now Aerial view
Norwalk apartment for rent - a living room with a gray couch and a large window
$2,653-$4,256 /mo

Brim and Crown

230 East Avenue, Norwalk, CT, 06855

Studio-2 beds 1-2 baths 553-1,351 sqft
View details
16
Rent specials Available now
Westport apartment for rent - a living room with a blue couch and a white table
$2,498-$4,870 /mo

1177 Greens Farms

1177 Post Road East, Westport, CT, 06880

Studio-1 bed 1 bath 471-803 sqft
View details
24
Available now Aerial view
West Haven apartment for rent - a kitchen with stainless steel appliances and white cabinets
$1,699-$2,000 /mo

Retro 511

511 Main Street, West Haven, CT, 06516

1-2 beds 1 bath 677-1,833 sqft
View details
33
Rent specials Available now
Fairfield apartment for rent - an open kitchen and living room with a table and chairs and a refrigerator
$2,229-$3,205 /mo

Alto Fairfield Metro

1401 Kings Hwy, Fairfield, CT, 06824

Studio-2 beds 1-2 baths 515-1,369 sqft
View details
39
Available now Aerial view
East Haven apartment for rent - a living room with a couch and a coffee table
$1,870-$1,970 /mo

Encore 99

99 Hemingway Avenue, East Haven, CT, 06512

1-2 beds 1 bath 720-920 sqft
View details
22
Available now Aerial view
Norwalk apartment for rent - a living room filled with furniture and a fireplace
$2,181-$5,495 /mo

Iron Works Sono

1 N Water St., Norwalk, CT, 06854

Studio-2 beds 1-2 baths 524-1,574 sqft
View details

Get to know Middle Island, NY

See what’s nearby

Minnesauke Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 642 students
9/10
Nassakeag Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 543 students
7/10
Setauket Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 604 students
7/10
North Coleman Road School
Public • PK, K-5 • 344 students
5/10
Arrowhead Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 571 students
5/10
Port Jefferson Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 364 students
5/10
River Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 300 students
5/10
William Sidney Mount School
Public • PK, K-6 • 511 students
5/10
Clayton Huey Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 598 students
5/10
West Middle Island School
Public • K-4 • 642 students
4/10
Longwood Middle School
Public • 5-6 • 1290 students
2/10
Middle Island Post Office
Public service
Holy Trinity Lutheran Church
Place of worship
City On A Hill Community Church
Place of worship
Community Baptist Church Of Gorden Heights
Place of worship
Holding Out Hope Church
Place of worship
Holy Trinity Lutheran Church
Place of worship
City On A Hill Community Church
Place of worship
Community Baptist Church Of Gorden Heights
Place of worship
Holding Out Hope Church
Place of worship
Middle Island Post Office
Public service
Longwood Library Community Room
Entertainment
Kovarik Room
Entertainment
Longwood Public Library
Entertainment
Clemens Room
Entertainment
Bayles Local History Room
Entertainment
Longwood Library Community Room
Entertainment
Kovarik Room
Entertainment
Longwood Public Library
Entertainment
Clemens Room
Entertainment
Bayles Local History Room
Entertainment

Average rent in Middle Island

In Middle Island, the average rent is $2,935 per month, with the average rental size around 1,051 square feet. Most renters here pay over $3,000, making it the most common rent bracket in the area.

Average rent
$2,935/month
Average rental size
1,051 sqft
Rent ranges
Under $1,000
0%
$1,001 - $1,500
0%
$1,501 - $2,000
0%
$2,001 - $2,500
29.6%
$2,501 - $3,000
26.7%
Over $3,000
43.7%
Rent data provided by Yardi® Matrix.
Curious how rent prices changed over time? Dive deeper into Middle Island's rent trends

Average utility cost in New York

In New York, renters typically spend around $470 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for internet to $148 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.

Electricity grafic icon
Electricity
$148
Gas grafic icon
Gas
$144
Water grafic icon
Water
$34
Sewer grafic icon
Sewer
$55
Cable grafic icon
Cable
$59
Internet grafic icon
Internet
$30
Rentals near me – Discover your next apartment with Point2Homes

Need a rental nearby? With Point2Homes, you can quickly browse listings for great apartments and single-family homes near your current location. Narrow down listings by price, number of bedrooms, outdoor space, or pet-friendliness. On your phone or desktop, it’s easy to find the right home near you or anywhere in the U.S. Start your local rental search now.

2-28-city