Skip to main content

$2,200-$2,725/mo

(1)

Blue Bay Inn

51 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716

Studio-1 bed 1 bath

All about this rental
apartment

Quick overview

Type:
Apartment
Neighborhood:
Atlantic Highlands
ZIP code:
07716
Status:
Active
Last checked:
1 hour ago

Find your perfect layout

Perks of living here

Shared spaces & benefits

  • Availability 24 Hours

Ready to see it in person?

Contact info
Kalian Companies
Property listed in the Yardi Rental ILS Network (RentCafe.com & Point2Homes.com).

Get to know the area

Know your way around

77
Very walkable
Walk Score®
N/A
No data
Transit Score®
66
Bikeable
Bike Score®
The area around 51 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716 is highly walkable. Many services and amenities are within walking distance, allowing you to handle most errands without a car. 51 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716 is in a moderately bikeable area, offering some cycling infrastructure to support local rides.
Walkability data provided by Walk Score®

Plan your commute

  • Atlantic Highlands's city center
    5 min
    4 min
    15 min
    17 min
Commute times provided by Walk Score® Travel Time.

See what’s nearby

Atlantic Highlands Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 256 students • 0.23 mi
6/10
Mother Teresa Regional School
Private • PK, K-8 • 125 students • 0.43 mi
NR
Highlands School
Public • PK, K-6 • 170 students • 2.30 mi
4/10
Deane-Porter Elementary School
Public • PK, K-3 • 384 students • 3.48 mi
NR
Viola L. Sickles Elementary School
Public • PK, K-3 • 452 students • 3.48 mi
NR
Fairview Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 302 students • 3.79 mi
8/10
Harmony Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 472 students • 4.39 mi
6/10
Ocean Avenue Elementary School
Public • PK, K-5 • 295 students • 4.45 mi
7/10
Atlantic Highlands Elementary School
Public • PK, K-6 • 256 students • 0.23 mi
6/10
Mother Teresa Regional School
Private • PK, K-8 • 125 students • 0.43 mi
NR
Navesink Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 208 students • 1.04 mi
8/10
Leonardo Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 275 students • 1.14 mi
3/10
Highlands School
Public • PK, K-6 • 170 students • 2.30 mi
4/10
Bayview Elementary School
Public • K-5 • 333 students • 2.47 mi
6/10
Deane-Porter Elementary School
Public • PK, K-3 • 384 students • 3.48 mi
NR
Viola L. Sickles Elementary School
Public • PK, K-3 • 452 students • 3.48 mi
NR
Mother Teresa Regional School
Private • PK, K-8 • 125 students • 0.43 mi
NR
Bayshore Middle School
Public • 6-8 • 561 students • 1.11 mi
7/10
Henry Hudson Reg School
Public • 7-12 • 296 students • 3.16 mi
4/10
Forrestdale Middle School
Public • 4-8 • 525 students • 3.48 mi
10/10
Knollwood Elementary School
Public • 4-8 • 510 students • 4.06 mi
9/10
Thorne Middle School
Public • 6-8 • 620 students • 4.30 mi
5/10
West Side Christian Academy
Private • 1-12 • 18 students • 4.44 mi
NR
St Marys School
Private • PK-8 • 427 students • 4.49 mi
NR
Henry Hudson Reg School
Public • 7-12 • 296 students • 3.16 mi
4/10
Middletown - North High School
Public • 9-12 • 1340 students • 3.36 mi
6/10
Rumson Fair Haven Regional High School
Public • 9-12 • 876 students • 3.67 mi
9/10
Marine Academy of Science and Technology
Public • 9-12 • 266 students • 3.73 mi
10/10
West Side Christian Academy
Private • 1-12 • 18 students • 4.44 mi
NR
Red Bank Reg High School
Public • 9-12 • 1195 students • 4.49 mi
5/10
Mater Dei Prep High School
Private • 9-12 • 316 students • 4.49 mi
NR
Red Bank Catholic High School
Private • 9-12 • 915 students • 4.82 mi
NR
Trackman's House
College • 7.81 mi
NR
Gorman Hall
College • 7.82 mi
NR
Brookdale Community College
College • 7.83 mi
NR
Brookdale Administration Center
College • 7.83 mi
NR
Larrison Hall
College • 7.84 mi
NR
Center for Admissions and Registration
College • 7.95 mi
NR
Main Academic North
College • 7.96 mi
NR
Advanced Technology Center
College • 7.96 mi
NR
Atlantic Highlands Trolley Stop
Bus
0.17 mi
NJ 36 at Main Street
Bus
2.85 mi
Garfield Avenue at Leonardville Road
Bus
2.93 mi
Highlands Seaplane Base
Airport
3.17 mi
Sandy Hook Beach
Bus
3.80 mi
Middletown
Train
4.45 mi
Middletown
Train
4.47 mi
Red Bank
Train
4.98 mi
Highlands Seaplane Base
Airport
3.17 mi
Hop Brook Farm Airport
Airport
8.83 mi
Atlantic Highlands Trolley Stop
Bus
0.17 mi
NJ 36 at Main Street
Bus
2.85 mi
Garfield Avenue at Leonardville Road
Bus
2.93 mi
Sandy Hook Beach
Bus
3.80 mi
Carr Avenue at Center Avenue
Bus
5.75 mi
Academy Exit 109
Bus
6.18 mi
Route 36 & Union
Bus
6.85 mi
Route 36 & Seagate
Bus
7.10 mi
Middletown
Train
4.45 mi
Middletown
Train
4.47 mi
Red Bank
Train
4.98 mi
Red Bank
Train
5.03 mi
Little Silver
Train
6.09 mi
Little Silver
Train
6.14 mi
Monmouth Park
Train
7.11 mi
Hazlet
Train
7.94 mi
Christine's
Restaurant
0.03 mi
The Wine Bar And Restaurant
Restaurant
0.04 mi
Hudsen Cafe
Restaurant
0.04 mi
Carton Brewing
Drinks
0.20 mi
On the Deck
Restaurant
0.22 mi
Shore Casino Restaurant
Restaurant
0.23 mi
McDonald's
Food
0.55 mi
El Ranchero
Restaurant
0.92 mi
Carton Brewing
Drinks
0.20 mi
The Sandbox at Seastreak Beach
Drinks
2.21 mi
The Chubby Pickle
Drinks
3.12 mi
The Bar at Beachwalk
Drinks
3.76 mi
Mule Barn Tavern
Drinks
3.91 mi
Olde Village Pub
Drinks
4.11 mi
Walt Street Pub
Drinks
4.95 mi
Raritan Bay Brewing Co.
Drinks
5.28 mi
McDonald's
Food
0.55 mi
Stewarts
Food
1.92 mi
Lot E Complex (Concession)
Food
2.99 mi
Lot C Concession Plaza
Food
3.02 mi
Lighthouse Strollo's Homemade Italian Ice
Food
3.06 mi
Dunkin' Donuts
Food
3.66 mi
Burger King
Food
3.70 mi
Dunkin'
Food
3.70 mi
Christine's
Restaurant
0.03 mi
The Wine Bar And Restaurant
Restaurant
0.04 mi
Hudsen Cafe
Restaurant
0.04 mi
On the Deck
Restaurant
0.22 mi
Shore Casino Restaurant
Restaurant
0.23 mi
El Ranchero
Restaurant
0.92 mi
Chiafullo's
Restaurant
1.02 mi
Jersey Shore Coffee Roasters
Restaurant
1.12 mi
Gateway Bar & Liquor Store
Shopping
1.01 mi
Quick Stop
Grocery store
1.02 mi
Dollar Tree
Shopping
1.03 mi
Goodwill
Shopping
1.03 mi
Wawa
Grocery store
1.52 mi
In The Garden
Shopping
2.42 mi
Kranky Cycles
Shopping
2.42 mi
One Stop Food Store
Grocery store
2.87 mi
Quick Stop
Grocery store
1.02 mi
Wawa
Grocery store
1.52 mi
One Stop Food Store
Grocery store
2.87 mi
7-Eleven
Grocery store
2.89 mi
7-Eleven
Grocery store
3.09 mi
Super Foodtown
Grocery store
3.46 mi
Krauszers
Grocery store
3.64 mi
7-Eleven
Grocery store
3.66 mi
Gateway Bar & Liquor Store
Shopping
1.01 mi
Dollar Tree
Shopping
1.03 mi
Goodwill
Shopping
1.03 mi
In The Garden
Shopping
2.42 mi
Kranky Cycles
Shopping
2.42 mi
Walgreens
Shopping
3.01 mi
Brennan's Delicatessen of Rumson
Shopping
3.04 mi
Fairwinds Deli
Shopping
3.45 mi
Atlantic Highlands Fire Department
Public service
0.15 mi
Central Baptist Church
Place of worship
0.21 mi
First Presbyterian Church
Place of worship
0.21 mi
Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church
Place of worship
0.33 mi
Henry Hudson Trail Activity Center
Public service
0.67 mi
Quinn Chapel African Methodist Episcopal Church
Place of worship
0.69 mi
Brevant Park Fire Company
Public service
0.94 mi
Croyden Hall Municipal Offices
Public service
1.00 mi
Wawa
Automotive
1.49 mi
Hartshorne Woods Park Buttermilk Valley Parking
Automotive
1.61 mi
Hartshorne Woods Park Buttermilk Valley Overflow Parking
Automotive
1.62 mi
Huber Woods Parking
Automotive
1.81 mi
Seastreak Overflow Parking
Automotive
2.02 mi
Seastreak Highlands Commuter Parking
Automotive
2.22 mi
Brian's Auto Tech
Automotive
2.25 mi
Auto Body Contours
Automotive
2.28 mi
Dr. Suzanne Grubowski, Family & Cosmetic Dentistry
Healthcare
2.75 mi
eMedical - Urgent Care
Healthcare
3.71 mi
Crestview Pharmacy
Healthcare
3.73 mi
Walgreens
Healthcare
3.75 mi
Acorn Pediatric Dental
Healthcare
4.01 mi
Oakwood Dental
Healthcare
4.01 mi
Riverview Medical Center
Healthcare
4.42 mi
Barnabas Health Medical Group - Monmouth Medical Center
Healthcare
4.44 mi
Comfort Inn
Hotel
3.66 mi
The Hub Middletown: a Best Western Signature Hotel
Hotel
3.70 mi
BeachWalk at Sea Bright
Hotel
3.77 mi
The Oyster Point Hotel
Hotel
4.54 mi
Windows on The Water
Hotel
4.61 mi
Molly Pitcher Inn
Hotel
4.66 mi
Driftwood Beach Club
Hotel
5.63 mi
Holly Hill Motel
Hotel
5.75 mi
Peter Cunha Real Estate Team
Other
2.82 mi
Dero
Other
3.19 mi
Middletown Walk Sales Office
Other
3.29 mi
Farmers Insurance - John Macchio
Other
3.60 mi
AAA Insurance
Other
3.67 mi
Allstate Insurance - Luis Ponce
Other
3.69 mi
Caldwell Banker Residential Brockerage
Other
3.69 mi
Dero
Other
3.70 mi
Rumson Therapeutic & Sports Massage Center
Personal care
3.04 mi
Frank and Anita's Hair Styling
Personal care
3.65 mi
Hot Tropics 2
Personal care
3.98 mi
Supercuts
Personal care
3.98 mi
Sunshine J Foot Spa
Personal care
3.98 mi
Onyx Nails
Personal care
4.00 mi
Sport Clips
Personal care
4.02 mi
Glam House Salon
Personal care
4.05 mi
K9 Resorts of Middletown
Pet care
3.67 mi
PetSmart
Pet care
4.48 mi
Middletown Animal Hospital
Pet care
4.52 mi
PetSmart
Pet care
5.54 mi
Pauls' Pet Boutique
Pet care
5.61 mi
Bayshore Veterinary Hospital
Pet care
6.31 mi
PETicures Luxury Spa & Grooming
Pet care
7.64 mi
Pet Supplies Plus
Pet care
7.75 mi
Central Baptist Church
Place of worship
0.21 mi
First Presbyterian Church
Place of worship
0.21 mi
Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church
Place of worship
0.33 mi
Quinn Chapel African Methodist Episcopal Church
Place of worship
0.69 mi
Ocean View Community Church
Place of worship
1.42 mi
All Saints' Memorial Church
Place of worship
1.45 mi
High Point Chapel
Place of worship
2.01 mi
Our Lady of Perpetual Help
Place of worship
2.82 mi
Atlantic Highlands Fire Department
Public service
0.15 mi
Henry Hudson Trail Activity Center
Public service
0.67 mi
Brevant Park Fire Company
Public service
0.94 mi
Croyden Hall Municipal Offices
Public service
1.00 mi
Navesink Hook & Ladder Company
Public service
1.10 mi
Navesink Hook and Ladder Company
Public service
1.11 mi
Community Fire Company
Public service
1.49 mi
Naval Weapons Station Earle
Public service
2.04 mi
Atlantic Cinema
Entertainment
0.08 mi
First Avenue Playhouse Dessert Theatre
Entertainment
0.18 mi
Atlantic Highlands Historica
Entertainment
0.29 mi
Hillside Park Basketball Court
Sports
0.74 mi
Croydon Hall Football Field
Sports
0.90 mi
Croydon Hall Baseball Fields
Sports
1.07 mi
Spermaceti Cove Life Boat Station
Entertainment
3.00 mi
Twin Lights Museum
Entertainment
3.03 mi
Atlantic Cinema
Entertainment
0.08 mi
First Avenue Playhouse Dessert Theatre
Entertainment
0.18 mi
Atlantic Highlands Historica
Entertainment
0.29 mi
Spermaceti Cove Life Boat Station
Entertainment
3.00 mi
Twin Lights Museum
Entertainment
3.03 mi
Power House
Entertainment
3.04 mi
VFW Post
Entertainment
3.39 mi
Lighthouse Keeper's Quarters
Entertainment
3.75 mi
Hillside Park Basketball Court
Sports
0.74 mi
Croydon Hall Football Field
Sports
0.90 mi
Croydon Hall Baseball Fields
Sports
1.07 mi
Middletown North Varsity Baseball Field
Sports
3.17 mi
Middletown North Varsity Softball Field
Sports
3.30 mi
Arnold Truex Field
Sports
3.31 mi
Evergreen Park Soccer Field
Sports
4.25 mi
Evergreen Park Basketball Court
Sports
4.31 mi

Average utility cost in New Jersey

In New Jersey, renters typically spend around $450 per month on utilities, with costs ranging from $30 for cable to $125 for electricity, depending on factors like home size, season, and usage.

Electricity grafic icon
Electricity
$125
Gas grafic icon
Gas
$94
Water grafic icon
Water
$66
Sewer grafic icon
Sewer
$95
Cable grafic icon
Cable
$30
Internet grafic icon
Internet
$40

Community reviews
How are these reviews collected?
4.4 (1 review)

What other renters say:

Verified Resident
Apr 30, 2025 • Sophie S.

Still looking? Here's more!

FAQs about Blue Bay Inn

When was this property’s information last updated?

The details for Blue Bay Inn were last updated 1 hour ago.

What floor plans are available?

Blue Bay Inn offers the following floor plan options: studio, one-bedroom.

Is Blue Bay Inn pet-friendly?

Yes, pets are welcome at Blue Bay Inn.

What neighborhood is this property in?

51 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716 is in Atlantic Highlands.

What are popular apartment communities in Atlantic Highlands?

How far is Blue Bay Inn from the city center?

Blue Bay Inn is approximately 5 minutes away by car from the city center.

What's the best way to get around the area?

The area around 51 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716 is highly walkable. Many services and amenities are within walking distance, allowing you to handle most errands without a car. 51 1st Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716 is in a moderately bikeable area, offering some cycling infrastructure to support local rides.

What schools are close by?

Nearby schools include Atlantic Highlands Elementary School, Mother Teresa Regional School, Navesink Elementary School.

What colleges are close by?

Nearby colleges include Trackman's House, Gorman Hall, Brookdale Community College.

What are the price ranges for the units in this building?

Prices in Blue Bay Inn are at:
  • From $2,200 for studios
  • $2,725 for one-bedroom units

How does this rent compare with rents in Atlantic Highlands?

Rent in Atlantic Highlands averages at $2,224, compared to prices of $2,200-$2,725 /mo at Blue Bay Inn.

Are there any other apartments around for the same amount?

Does the rent at Blue Bay Inn include utilities?

No, utilities are not included in the rent at Blue Bay Inn. Tenants are typically responsible for all utilities.

Are there any reviews or ratings related to Blue Bay Inn or its management company?

Yes, you’ll find reviews for Blue Bay Inn above—see what past and current residents have to say about living here.

Cast a wider net